welcome to the online home of ms. atkinson's english 11 class
Friday, April 23, 2010
Discussion Question 1
What kind of marriage do you think Macbeth and Lady Macbeth have? Who has more power in the relationship?
6 comments:
Anonymous
said...
The relationship between Macbeth and Lady Macbeth are having doesnt seems to be an actual husband and wife would really do. I mean, Lady Macbeth is persuading Macbeth to go on her way, she is literally controlling him. An acutual relationship is about compromise, and are willing to take sacrifices for each other. In conclusion, Lady Macbeth has more power.
Macbeth and Lady Macbeth do not have a very good relationship. Lady Macbeth controls Macbeth and she has the most power over him. There is no sense of true love nor communication. She just keeps on telling him what to do. Relatioships are based on sacrifices and understanding which Lady Macbeth does not show towards him. -Nina
There is really no question in this, Macbeth is whipped to no end. Using stubborn logic, Lady Macbeth is able to persuade Macbeth against his beliefs and commit murder? That truly shows how easily Macbeth will succumb to the lady's wishes.
I think the relationship between Macbeth and Lady Macbeth poor because Macbeth can't object Lady Macbeth when he feels it is wrong to do that. Lady Macbeth seems to have more power persuading Macbeth and ordering to do everything she ask him to do.
Lady Macbeth clearly wears the pants in the relationship. I see that in their marriage she is quite manipulative in nature. I would never let my spouse walk all over me like Macbeth does. Persuading someone to change an annoying habit is one thing, but talking them into murder is another.
The relationship between mcbeth and lady mcbeth is very poor. Lady mcbeth uses mcbeth to murder and so he can become the king. She doesnt think aboiut anything else like if she did kill anyone he would go to jail and they wouldnt be together for a long time or perhaps forever if its a huge crime. She brings him down by saying ur not man enough to kill so he is bascially forced to kill. If u want a relationship to be good u have to sacriffice for eachother and be happy with no matter wat u have.
6 comments:
The relationship between Macbeth and Lady Macbeth are having doesnt seems to be an actual husband and wife would really do. I mean, Lady Macbeth is persuading Macbeth to go on her way, she is literally controlling him. An acutual relationship is about compromise, and are willing to take sacrifices for each other. In conclusion, Lady Macbeth has more power.
Alex Cho
Macbeth and Lady Macbeth do not have a very good relationship. Lady Macbeth controls Macbeth and she has the most power over him. There is no sense of true love nor communication. She just keeps on telling him what to do. Relatioships are based on sacrifices and understanding which Lady Macbeth does not show towards him.
-Nina
There is really no question in this, Macbeth is whipped to no end. Using stubborn logic, Lady Macbeth is able to persuade Macbeth against his beliefs and commit murder? That truly shows how easily Macbeth will succumb to the lady's wishes.
I think the relationship between Macbeth and Lady Macbeth poor because Macbeth can't object Lady Macbeth when he feels it is wrong to do that. Lady Macbeth seems to have more power persuading Macbeth and ordering to do everything she ask him to do.
-Angela
Lady Macbeth clearly wears the pants in the relationship. I see that in their marriage she is quite manipulative in nature. I would never let my spouse walk all over me like Macbeth does. Persuading someone to change an annoying habit is one thing, but talking them into murder is another.
Helena
The relationship between mcbeth and lady mcbeth is very poor. Lady mcbeth uses mcbeth to murder and so he can become the king. She doesnt think aboiut anything else like if she did kill anyone he would go to jail and they wouldnt be together for a long time or perhaps forever if its a huge crime. She brings him down by saying ur not man enough to kill so he is bascially forced to kill. If u want a relationship to be good u have to sacriffice for eachother and be happy with no matter wat u have.
Post a Comment